Ensuring your baby gets sound sleep begins with picking the best crib mattress. Be it the resilience of memory foam, the classic feel of innerspring mattresses, or the safety of an organic mattress, the choice can be overwhelming.

Especially with sudden infant death syndrome concerns, parents are searching for mattresses devoid of polyurethane foam. The preference for an organic cotton-based crib mattress is rising, while others still value the durability of traditional foam crib mattresses.

This review will guide you in selecting the most suitable crib mattress for your little one.

Our Top Picks

• Best for Breathability: Lullaby Earth Breathe Safe 2-Stage Breathable Crib Mattress
• Best Eco-Friendly Choice: ECO ORGANIC CRIB MATTRESS
• Best for Waterproof Features: Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed – Waterproof
• Best for Comfort: Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress
• Best All-Rounder: Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed – 100% Breathable

Lullaby Earth Breathe Safe 2-Stage Breathable Crib Mattress

When it comes to ensuring a safe and comfortable sleep for your little one, the Lullaby Earth Breathe Safe 2-Stage Breathable Crib Mattress stands out. Made from environmentally friendly materials, this mattress promises durability and safety, ensuring your baby a peaceful night’s rest.

Key Features

• Advanced 3D honeycomb structure, offering genuine airflow and breathability.
• The Double Waterproof design includes a laminate behind the 3D structure and a wipe-clean waterproof surface on the core.
• 2-Stage dual firmness ensures varying firmness levels suitable for both infants and toddlers.
• Super lightweight design at only 8 lbs, simplifying the process of changing the crib.
• Absence of harmful chemicals, such as polyurethane foam, vinyl PVC, PFC water-resistant treatments, and GMOs.

Pros

• The mattress cover is breathable and improves temperature regulation, reducing the risk of overheating.
• The removable cover offers ease of cleaning; it’s machine washable.
• Patented wave support inner provides the necessary firmness while being lightweight.
• Made of organic materials, it ensures a natural and non-toxic environment for the baby.
• Meets all flammability requirements without using chemical flame retardants.

Cons

• The packaging may vary, which might concern those particular about aesthetic consistency.

Why Is the Lullaby Earth Breathe Safe 2-Stage Breathable Crib Mattress a Good Choice?

Based on our assessment, we found this crib mattress to stand tall among many available crib mattresses. Its unique 3D honeycomb design ensures genuine breathability, a key feature to reduce the risk factors associated with sudden infant death syndrome.

Being one of the best crib mattresses, it steers clear from the traditional memory foam mattresses, embracing an organic approach.

The absence of harmful chemicals is a testament to its commitment to offering the best organic crib mattress experience. The dual firmness design caters to both the crib and toddler mattress needs, making it a versatile choice for long-term use.

Considering the toddler side, organic cotton fabric, and certified organic standards, this mattress offers peace of mind for parents looking for a foam crib mattress alternative. We feel confident in recommending this mattress to parents who prioritize safety, comfort, and organic materials for their little ones.

Organic Breathable Baby Crib & Toddler Mattress – Lightweight 2 Stage

The Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Lightweight Crib Mattress is a beacon of safety and comfort in baby crib mattresses. Prioritizing organic materials over harmful chemicals, this mattress ensures the purest sleep environment for your little one.

Key Features

• Wipe clean, waterproof surface aligns with food contact standards.
• Waterproof seams to resist moisture penetration and aid in cleaning.
• Furnished with certified organic cotton fabric and filling.
• Embedded with firm yet comfortable wave support technology using 100% food-grade polyethylene.
• Lightweight design, weighing between 10-12 pounds for easy handling.

Pros

• Actively avoids the common harmful chemicals found in many crib mattresses.
• Follows CPSC and pediatrician guidelines, ensuring firm crib mattress support and a snug fit.
• Waterproof mattress design with heat-sealed seams keeps dust mites and bed bugs at bay.
• Uses U.S.-grown certified organic cotton, a genuine mark of quality.
• Reinforced edges prevent the baby from getting trapped on the sides.

Cons

• While it focuses on organic material, some parents might miss the plush comfort of foam or innerspring mattress options.

Why Is the Organic Breathable Baby Crib & Toddler Mattress – Lightweight 2 Stage a Good Choice?

In our experience, the shift towards organic materials in the mattress industry is not just a trend—it’s a response to genuine concerns over harmful chemicals in crib mattresses.

We found peace of mind with this mattress, knowing our baby wouldn’t be exposed to volatile organic compounds and chemical flame retardants often associated with non-organic options.

Its lightweight nature came as a boon when we had to do frequent sheet changes, making it arguably one of the best crib mattresses of 2023. Its firmness, adhering to expert guidelines, gives the impression of an enhanced safety measure against potential risks like infant death syndrome (SIDS).

For any parent considering a crib and toddler mattress, this organic crib mattress emerges as a stellar choice, balancing health, safety, and convenience.

Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed – Waterproof

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress is a shining example of how innovation meets safety in crib mattresses. Ensuring that your little one’s sleep is both sound and safe, this mattress is designed with advanced technology to address the common concerns of parents.

Key Features

• Integrated with Breathe-Thru Technology, making the mattress 100% breathable.
• Fully washable cover, right down to its core, facilitating easy cleaning.
• No foam, glue, latex, or springs – making it entirely recyclable.
• Dual-sided mattress for infants and toddlers with a protective, waterproof, yet breathable lining on the toddler side.
• Proudly GREENGUARD Gold Certified, backing its claims of safety and quality.

Pros

• Directly combats the risks associated with suffocation and CO2 rebreathing.
• Eliminates common allergens with its hypoallergenic features.
• It offers optimal comfort, support, and air circulation, promising better sleep for your baby.
• It was constructed without the typical materials found in foam or innerspring mattresses, boosting its eco-friendliness.
• Pediatrician-endorsed, ensuring that it’s a product trusted by professionals.

Cons

• Some parents accustomed to memory foam mattresses or traditional innerspring crib mattresses might initially find the feel unfamiliar.

Why Is the Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed – Waterproof a Good Choice?

Our experience shows an increasing need for innovative solutions in baby crib mattresses. The Newton Baby Crib Mattress doesn’t just tick the boxes; it goes beyond. We felt relieved knowing the Breathe-Thru Technology was hard at work, minimizing any suffocation risks.

Beyond safety, a fully washable cover seemed like a dream, especially considering those unavoidable diaper leaks.

Unlike many crib mattresses, the absence of typical materials like polyurethane foam speaks volumes about its environmental commitment. This is, without a doubt, one of the best crib mattresses of 2023, striking the right balance between innovation, safety, and ecological consciousness.

When it’s time to upgrade to a toddler bed, the dual-sided mattress ensures longevity, making it not just a purchase but an investment for your child’s well-being.

ORGANIC CRIB MATTRESS

When it comes to providing the safest and most comfortable resting place for your little one, the Organic Crib Mattress emerges as a remarkable choice.

Handmade in Los Angeles and constructed from certified organic materials, this mattress aligns with your child’s essential needs while being kind to the planet.

Key Features

• Crafted from certified organic cotton, wool, and latex to ensure top-tier safety.
• It is designed with a dual-sided feature catering to both infants and toddlers.
• Proudly holds a GREENGUARD Gold certification.
• Coconut fiber infusion paired with 100% GOLS organic certified latex and 100% GOTS organic certified wool and cotton.
• Made without harmful elements like petroleum-based polyurethane foams, chemical adhesives, or flame retardant chemicals.

Pros

• A notable focus on affordability without compromising organic integrity.
• Enhanced durability and breathability due to the use of organic cotton, wool, and latex.
• Materials are sustainably and responsibly harvested, ensuring environmental responsibility.
• The dual-sided design offers longevity, saving the hassle of purchasing another crib mattress for years.
• The absence of hazardous chemicals provides children with a pure and safe sleeping environment.

Cons

• Some parents might need to learn about the familiarity of traditional foam mattresses.

Why Is the ORGANIC CRIB MATTRESS a Good Choice?

After exploring the many features of this mattress, we couldn’t help but be impressed. The commitment to certified organic materials immediately captured our attention.

Unlike many crib mattresses, this one is crafted without any trace of harmful or synthetic elements, making it stand tall among the best crib mattresses on the market. The dual-sided design left us feeling confident about its longevity.

We could envision a baby sleeping peacefully on the infant side and then, as they grow, flipping the mattress to the toddler side. It’s rare to find such thoughtful engineering paired with strict organic standards.

This isn’t just a mattress; it’s a commitment to your child’s well-being and the environment. This choice will surely pay off in comfort, safety, and peace of mind for parents looking to make a wise, long-lasting investment in crib mattresses.

ECO ORGANIC CRIB MATTRESS

The Eco Organic Crib Mattress shows how modern ingenuity can align with Mother Nature’s best. Made in Los Angeles, this crib mattress combines the luxury of organic materials with the reassurance of top-notch certifications.

Whether it’s the unparalleled comfort of organic cotton and wool or the robust support of encased coils, this mattress promises sound sleep for the youngest members of your family.

Key Features

• 3.5” encased coils made in-house for top-tier support.
• Incorporates GOTS-certified organic cotton, wool, and two layers of coconut husk for unmatched comfort.
• Certified absence of harmful substances like chemical flame retardants, fiberglass, or polyurethane foams.
• Sports has a GREENGUARD Gold Certification and is Formaldehyde Free Certified by UL Environment.
• MADE SAFE® certified, guaranteeing it meets rigorous safety standards.
• Natural thermoregulation properties, ensuring the mattress remains naturally cool.
• Materials are Blockchain-verified for authenticity and traceability.
• GOLS-certified organic coconut husk pad infused with organic latex offers added coolness and comfort.

Pros

• Priced competitively, rivaling traditional foam mattresses yet offering superior organic quality.
• Exclusively uses materials sourced responsibly, such as GOTS-certified organic wool and cotton.
• Crafted without using harmful chemicals, ensuring a safe sleep environment.
• Boasts exceptional volatile organic compounds (VOCs) standards, prioritizing user safety.
• Steel coils are constructed from recycled steel, promoting sustainability while ensuring durability.

Cons

• Some might find the absence of a removable cover or waterproof cover limiting for maintenance and durability.

Why Is the ECO ORGANIC CRIB MATTRESS a Good Choice?

Having personally explored the features of this mattress, we’re genuinely impressed. When most crib mattresses often compromise on materials or safety standards, the Eco Organic Crib Mattress stands out.

It’s not just about being organic; it’s about ensuring the entire mattress meets and often exceeds the most stringent safety standards. Every parent seeks the best crib mattress for their child, and this might just be it.

The dedication to sustainable, safe, and comfortable materials is evident, from the organic wool to the recycled steel coils.

Furthermore, with natural thermoregulation properties, restless nights due to overheating are a thing of the past. For parents searching for a trustworthy, long-lasting, and comfortable crib mattress, this stellar investment ensures peace of mind and safe sleep for their little one.

Breathable 2-Stage Crib Mattress

When it comes to ensuring that your baby gets the safest, most comfortable sleep, the Breathable 2-Stage Crib Mattress stands out. Boasting an impressive patented Wovenaire core made predominantly of free air, this mattress ensures your baby can breathe through it.

Beyond the breathability, the comfort is elevated by its plush dual-layer quilted cloud cover, making it a remarkable choice amongst other crib mattresses.

Key Features

• Patented Wovenaire core composed of 90% free air.
• Dual-layer quilted cloud cover that’s both breathable and plush.
• No polyurethane foam, metal springs, glue, or adhesives used.
• Greenguard Gold certified, indicating lower VOCs and no foam, latex, or allergens.
• The 2-stage design ensures use through infancy to toddler years.
• Entirely washable material, even the core.
• Temperature regulation to deter overheating.
• Compliant with standard crib mattress dimensions.

Pros

• Exceptional breathability, proven by a third-party CPSC-accredited laboratory.
• A waterproof cover that’s easily unzipped for machine washing.
• Hypoallergenic and 100% recyclable materials.
• Organic mattress characteristics without the actual organic components.
• Easy cleaning, even with a hose or in the shower.
• Manufactured in the USA, ensuring quality.

Cons

• Lacks certified organic materials for those explicitly seeking an organic product.
• It may require frequent washing due to its high breathability, especially in a high-humidity environment.

Why Is the Breathable 2-Stage Crib Mattress a Good Choice?

From our analysis, it’s evident that this mattress offers a unique blend of safety and comfort.

The core, made of 90% free air, is a game-changer. We’ve seen many crib mattresses that stand out, especially considering the airiness and hypoallergenic qualities.

We loved that cleaning is a breeze, from the waterproof cover to the core. It’s not just another foam crib mattress; it’s a revolution in baby sleep. The dual-stage design also caught our eye.

Why invest in multiple mattresses when this serves the baby and toddler? The Greenguard Gold certified status further solidifies its position in the best crib mattress category.

For a parent looking to balance comfort, safety, and durability, the Breathable 2-Stage Crib Mattress is a wise choice.

Breathable Mini Crib Mattress

The Breathable Mini Crib Mattress is a testament to providing your baby with health, safety, and comfort.

The defining feature is the patented Wovenaire core, ingeniously made of 90% free air. This ensures superior comfort and an innovative design through which your baby can easily breathe.

It is wrapped in a soft single-layer eyelet cover and boasts a natural viscose lining. This lining epitomizes the brand’s commitment to natural, chemical-free solutions that meet rigorous safety standards.

Key Features

• Patented Wovenaire core made of 90% air.
• Single-layer eyelet cover complemented by a natural viscose lining.
• No polyurethane foam, adhesives, metal springs, or glue used.
• Greenguard gold certified, ensuring low chemical emissions.
• Designed with a 2-stage system, suitable for infants transitioning to toddlers.
• A washable cover and a core can be cleaned even in the bath/shower.
• Firmness tailored for babies’ needs, complying with the Australian Firmness Standard.
• Lead & phthalate-free, meeting all ASTM and CPSC standards.

Pros

• Exceptional breathability as validated by a third-party CPSC-accredited lab.
• Naturepedic organic lightweight classic approach without the weight.
• Versatile, washable cover and core.
• Safe sleep is promoted through a firm mattress that’s both comfortable and secure.
• Green mattress commitment is shown in recyclability and Greenguard gold certified status.
• Machine washable components simplify cleaning.

Cons

• It might be too firm for parents seeking a plush feel for their toddlers.
• Single-layer covers might not offer the same cushioning effect as dual-sided crib mattresses.
• Viscose lining, though natural, might not resonate with those specifically looking for organic mattresses.

Why Is the Breathable Mini Crib Mattress a Good Choice?

Diving deep into this product, we found the Breathable Mini Crib Mattress to be a harmonious blend of safety and comfort. The Wovenaire core sets this apart from all the crib mattresses we’ve encountered.

This feature makes it an innovative crib mattress, fostering a safe sleep environment by ensuring the baby gets ample air even when face down.

The washable cover is a godsend for parents. We’ve faced our fair share of changing sheets during late nights, and knowing that this baby crib mattress offers an easily washable solution brings peace of mind.

The mattress’s Greenguard gold-certified status and alignment with the global organic textile standard further emphasize the commitment to safety.

Another fascinating aspect is the firmness. While some might see it as a con, we believe the delicate balance between a firm mattress and comfort is vital for a baby’s crib mattress. And this mini crib mattress seems to strike that balance beautifully.

The lack of harmful chemicals and the brand’s emphasis on eco-friendliness make it a commendable green mattress.

This natural approach, devoid of even synthetic latex, is refreshing in a world filled with baby gear that often leans towards synthetic materials. The mini size also means it can adapt to toddler beds, making it a versatile pick for the early years of a child’s life.

The Breathable Mini Crib Mattress is a thoughtful blend of innovation, safety, and comfort. Its features resonate with the needs of contemporary parents, undeniably making it an excellent choice for those seeking a reliable, eco-friendly sleep solution for their babies.

Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress

Introducing the Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress, an epitome of comfort and safety for your little one’s restful nights.

Combining optimal firmness with high-quality breathable foam, this mattress ensures your child enjoys superior comfort without compromising safety.

Designed to suit standard full-size cribs and toddler beds. The Graco Premium ensures convenience with its easy-to-carry packaging and other user-friendly features.

Key Features

• Shipped compressed in a lightweight box for easy transport.
• Soft outer cover that’s water resistant, removable, and hand-washable.
• Made with breathable foam to enhance air circulation.
• GREENGUARD Gold certified, ensuring low chemical emissions for improved indoor air quality.
• Fits standard full-size cribs and toddler beds.
• Water-resistant inner lining to keep the mattress dry.
• Anti-static and anti-microbial, adhering to federal flammability standards.
• Backed by a generous 6-year limited warranty.

Pros

• Hassle-free setup with self-expansion upon unpackaging.
• Best crib mattress firmness for infant and toddler safety.
• Free from harmful substances like phthalates and lead.
• Easy maintenance with a removable and washable outer cover.
• Lightweight design, making sheet changes less cumbersome.
• Proactive inner lining to ward off any accidental spills.

Cons

• It might take up to 72 hours to expand fully.
• It lacks the dual-firmness option that some dual-sided crib mattresses offer.
• It’s not an organic mattress, which some parents might prefer.

Why Is the Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress a Good Choice?

In our assessment of crib mattresses, the Graco Premium stands out as a smart choice for discerning parents. When it comes to ensuring our children get the best, this mattress ticks many boxes.

Its breathability is a feature we genuinely appreciate. The enhanced air circulation means a cooler, more comfortable sleep for the baby. This foam mattress isn’t just about comfort; it brings commendable safety.

The GREENGUARD Gold certified tag has been vetted for low chemical emissions, crucial in a child’s sleep environment.

The design of this mattress ensures it fits perfectly in standard cribs and toddler beds, making it versatile and long-lasting.

The water-resistant features, both in the outer cover and inner lining, offer a practical solution for those accidents that are bound to happen.

Knowing that the entire mattress won’t get soaked is a relief, and the easy-to-wash cover adds another layer of convenience.

In an arena teeming with the best crib mattresses, the Graco Premium stands tall with its user-friendly features, top-tier safety standards, and durable build. While it might not be an organic mattress or have the advantage of dual-sided mattresses, it more than compensates for its myriad other benefits.

If you’re looking for a reliable, safe, and comfortable mattress for your child, the Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress should undoubtedly be on your shortlist.

Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress

Meet the Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress – where luxury meets baby’s comfort. Topped with high-quality memory foam and a firmer foam base, it promises nights of undisturbed sleep for your little one.

Key Features

• Combination of a firm foam base with a top layer of high-quality memory foam.
• Ultra-soft bamboo cover that is machine washable.
• Hypoallergenic Certi-Pur certified foam resisting allergens, mold, and dust mites.
• Superior 3lb memory foam construction ensuring durability and retaining shape.
• Standard size fitting at 27.5”x52”x5.5″, suitable for all standard cribs.

Pros

• Enhanced comfort and support with the foam base + memory foam top layer.
• Allergy-friendly choice with its hypoallergenic properties.
• Ultra-soft waterproof bamboo encasement, easy to clean.
• Memory foam that outshines others with its 3lb. construction.
• Versatile transition from a crib to a toddler crib mattress.

Cons

• Lacks the dual-firmness feature present in some dual-sided crib mattresses.
• It’s not an innerspring mattress, which some parents might prefer.

Why Is the Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress a Good Choice?

Our take on the Milliard Premium Memory Foam Mattress celebrates its blend of durability with luxury. It’s more than just a place for your child to rest.

Its high-quality innerspring mattress-like feel minus the springs offers a plush comfort that’s hard to match. The hypoallergenic properties make it an apt choice for babies with sensitivities, giving parents one less worry.

The waterproof mattress ensures easy cleaning, making those little accidents a breeze. Coupled with the crib sheets, this mattress ensures an uninterrupted, cozy sleep environment.

If a good night’s sleep for your baby is a priority, this mattress undoubtedly is a brilliant choice.

Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed – 100% Breathable

Meet the Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed, a breath of fresh air in infant sleep solutions. Pioneering with its Breathe-Thru Technology, it promises safety, comfort, and a night of deep sleep for your young one.

Key Features

• 100% Breathable design with Breathe-Thru Technology.
• It is fully washable from cover to core, making it the only 100% washable crib mattress.
• Free from foam, glue, latex, and springs, ensuring 100% recyclability.
• Dual-stage, supporting both infants and toddlers.
• Boasts the GREENGUARD Gold Certified tag, ensuring optimal safety.

Pros

• Revolutionary breathability, reducing risks related to suffocation.
• Hygiene-friendly with a fully washable design.
• Eco-friendly, being the only fully recyclable crib mattress in the market.
• Endorsed by pediatricians, reinforcing its safety and quality.
• Adaptable, with its infant and toddler (2-stage) feature.

Cons

• Not being an innerspring mattress, it might not cater to all preferences.
• It might be pricier compared to other best crib mattresses in the market.

Why Is the Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed a Good Choice?

In our experience, the Newton Baby Crib Mattress stands out as a paradigm of innovation. With its Breathe-Thru Technology, it addresses one of parents’ primary concerns: safety.

When paired with mattress covers or crib sheets, it ensures an environment where your baby can breathe freely, even if they’re face down. Its full washability is a boon for maintaining hygiene, something that’s essential given how messy baby years can be.

The fact that it’s entirely recyclable resonates with eco-conscious parents, and its dual-stage feature ensures longevity, potentially serving multiple children. The GREENGUARD Gold Certified tag and pediatrician recommendation further solidify our trust in this product.

If the goal is to combine innovation, safety, and eco-friendliness, the Newton Baby Crib Mattress is undoubtedly a top contender.

Final Thoughts

Reviewing the baby crib mattresses, we’ve looked closely at some standout options. From the breathable designs of Lullaby Earth Breathe Safe and Newton Baby Crib Mattress to the eco-friendly materials of ECO ORGANIC CRIB MATTRESS, the choices are varied but all high-quality. The comfort of Milliard Premium Memory Foam also caught our attention, ensuring our little ones sleep soundly.

When selecting the ideal mattress, it’s crucial to consider factors like safety, materials, ease of cleaning, durability, and comfort. Every parent will prioritize differently, but the market has choices to cater to every need.

With the options we’ve explored, you’re well on your way to making an informed decision for those peaceful nights ahead. Safe dreams!